Credit: CraSH/imageSPACE / MEGA
Scheana Shay named her best celebrity hookup during a podcast appearance over the summer as she spoke about her past with two actors from The Notebook.
While also admitting that the rules of her job at a member’s only club in Los Angeles never would’ve stopped her from dating John Mayer, 47, the 40-year-old Vanderpump Rules alum, who first opened up about her rendezvous with 11 famous men in her book, My Good Side, explained her attraction to celebrities as she confessed that most of her run-ins were “not dating” relationships.
“A lot of these were hookups. Some were once, some were multiple times. Like Jesse Metcalfe, fully dated. Like, yes, we were dating,” Scheana shared on the Not Skinny But Not Fat podcast, via PEOPLE. “But some of them, I mean, it was over a year, it was over two years. There were several consistent ones in the rotation.”
When asked about her “best hookup,” Scheana didn’t hesitate to name Shemar Moore, 55. However, she also noted that she was “careful with what details [she] shared” in her book. Although Scheana said that public figures were “fair game” to speak of, she also wanted to be “respectful” to those mentioned.
“I’m not trying to write a tell-all book about anyone other than myself,” she continued, signaling to the fact that some men were left unnamed, including the men from The Notebook. In fact, when asked if she was referring to Ryan Gosling, 44, Scheana said, “Not confirming or [denying].”
“Maybe there’s another book one day,” she teased.
Looking back at her time working at a private cigar club in Beverly Hills, where she met many famous men, Scheana said she wasn’t “allowed to fraternize with the members.”
“John also wasn’t a member of the Beverly Hills Club, but apparently he was a member of the New York club, which I didn’t know about and honestly wouldn’t have cared. I still would have done it. It’s John Mayer,” she stated.
Admittedly, Scheana wasn’t just attracted to the men’s personalities. She also enjoyed their status as celebrities.
“I mean, Jesse Metcalfe, like I had a crush on him just from watching him on TV when I was in college. The hot gardener on Desperate Housewives and then John Tucker. I mean, when I met him it was like, ‘Oh my God. This is Jesse Metcalfe,’” she recalled. “But then he was just a normal guy who liked to play the guitar for me and take me on dates and stuff. So there was definitely that appeal back in the day. But they all were genuinely nice guys. Like there’s not one guy I named in there who was an a**holes.”
Looking back, Scheana said all of her past relationships “naturally just fizzled out.”
“I had someone new in the rotation, so that one went out or this one went on tour, this one was filming or whatever,” she laughed.