Credit: Instagram
Summer House fans are in an uproar after learning that Paige DeSorbo‘s boyfriend, Joe D’Amelio, was romantically linked to Real Housewives of New Jersey star Teresa Giudice before she married Luis Ruelas.
Days after Paige, 33, confirmed that she and Joe were “exclusive” after what seemed to be over a year of dating, a resurfaced article shared by Reality Blurb in March 2020 showcased the flirty interactions that Joe and Teresa engaged in years ago, leading some to express concern for the Giggly Squad podcast host.
“Paige went public … But if you were deep in Bravo comments in 2020… this name is not new,” the Toronto Pop Zone reminded its followers on Instagram on February 28.
“The screenshots? Still thriving,” it added as it included a series of posts from late 2019 and early 2020.
“All dressed up love it,” Teresa wrote in the comments section of one of Joe’s pics.
“When’s our flight next trip?” Teresa commented on another post of Joe’s.
She also posted a series of fire emojis under a shirtless image of Joe.
Joe also shared comments under her photos, including one of a Sunday dinner with her family.
“I’ll go to the diner,” Joe wrote.
“Stop it I told you to come over,” Teresa replied.
View this post on Instagram
After the fan page’s post was shared, people flooded the comments section with their thoughts.
“Eeeeyuck! He’s a Bravo chaser. Hope our girl drops him,” one person shared.
“As a giggler, I really want to pretend I never saw this,” another admitted.
“If I was Paige this would give me an incurable ick,” added a third.
Some questioned if Joe was desperate to be involved with Bravo.
“What? Is he the next [Slade Smiley]?” another person asked of Gretchen Rossi‘s fiancé, who was linked to a number of Real Housewives of Orange County stars before her.
Then, someone else said, “He’s the new Harry Dubin,” signaling his past ties to the ladies of The Real Housewives of New York City.
“Looks like we have a Bravo fanatic on our hands,” another user agreed.
Paige DeSorbo exited Summer House in June 2025 after seven seasons.