Credit: Instagram
Hailey Glassman accused Erin Lichy of owing her both the Jam of the Month and $2,000 during an interview at the end of last month.
After the ladies were seen venturing to Erika Hammond‘s private island, Moskito Island, on the latest episode of The Real Housewives of New York City, Hailey, 39, said that Erin, 39, had lied about the jam, which she mentioned in response to Hailey suggesting she was as boring as jam, and failed to pay her for a dare.
“She is strawberry jam, but not — when I said not boogie jam — by the way, the Jam of the Month, that was just a fabrication of a lie. I never got my Jam of the Month,” Hailey shared on the September 29 episode of Page Six’s Virtual Reali-Tea. “She never did, and she owes me $2,000 from Moskito Island, which I Venmo requested her the other day.”
The $2000 appears to be from a pool dare during which Daisy Toye and Erin seemingly promised her $1000 to jump in the pool.
After showing proof of her Venmo request, describing their drama as “nonsense,” Hailey shaded Erin’s past issues with her landlord, saying, “I’m sure she’s gonna pay me back the same time she pays her management back.”
Hailey then recalled their first RHONY scene, clarifying that it was filmed “the second or third time [she] ever met [Erin],” which is why she appeared unmoved by Erin’s emotions about her daughter.
“I kept it real. I didn’t come in through anyone, so when she’s crying to me about her daughter, first of all, I didn’t even know [she] had a daughter,” Hailey explained. “And then she comes over and goes through all my stuff. Okay. Then she’s telling me my pied-à-terre is not a pied-à-terre and it has to be somewhere else. No, the definition is a part-time home.”
According to Hailey, she didn’t feel that Erin was truly wanting to get to know her. Instead, she felt that she was prying for information to use against her.
“You ever talk to someone and know that all they want to do is fish for something to then hurt you with? I have that instinct. I don’t know if it’s what I’ve been through in my life, but I have that instinct when someone’s talking to you if they’re trying to actually get to connect and know you or just like find out info to kind of dagger you with it,” Hailey said.
Meanwhile, on the October 6 episode of the RHONY: After Show, Erin reacted to Jessel Taank, 46, suggesting that her home flood was an insurance ploy.
“I just lost my whole house … It’s so mean and like tasteless,” Erin stated. “[And] where does she get off talking about my finances? I don’t know what she does for work … I don’t believe that she pays rent. If she’s gonna open the door, I pay for my kids’ school. I pay for rent. We know what my husband does. I don’t know what hers does. He’s an influencer?”
After Erin alleged that Jessel lived in a “glass house,” and Jessel said that when it came to her insurance comment, her “mind just went there,” Erika, 35, recalled Daisy Toye “[running] her mouth” about the topic.
“Daisy was very much involved in that conversation. You’re throwing us under the bus, but you were very much involved in that conversation,” Jessel agreed. “Daisy did not defend that girl, not one second. She questioned how Erin affords all the Chanel she buys, and by the way, that was the tip of the iceberg. We spoke about a lot more.”
Although Daisy seemingly defended herself, saying, “I didn’t think that you were gonna be like hysterical and then calling me,” Erika suspected that Daisy told Erin about the discussion because she was “obviously feeling guilty” about her involvement.
Daisy then said that she almost didn’t tell Erin about what Jessel said because she “didn’t want to hurt [her].”
“I’m happy you did because if you didn’t, I think I would’ve been more upset with you,” Erin replied.
After noting that Daisy was a part of their “insurance” discussion, Jessel confirmed she stood by the idea that Erin was a “one-man Ponzi scheme”.
“I do stand by [Erin being a Ponzi scheme]. It’s almost like she’s building bricks to this false narrative. A facade. She’s like selling you a dream, but there is no dream,” Jessel declared.
As for the status of her house today, Erin confirmed the downstairs was still not fixed.
“I’m living upstairs in the guest room. [And] what sucks about it is my insurance didn’t cover relocation or my items … and I usually at least rent a couple weeks,” she shared.
The Real Housewives of New York City season 16 airs Tuesdays at 8/7c on Bravo.