Scheana Shay Addresses Billie Lee’s ‘Inaccurate’ Threesome Claim, What Raquel Told Her About James Split, and Teddi Mellencamp’s Allegations Regarding James’ Fight With Ally

by Lindsay Cronin Comments
16 comments

Scheana Shay Addresses Billie Lee's 'Inaccurate' Threesome Claim, What Raquel Told Her About James Split, and Teddi Mellencamp's Allegations Regarding James' Fight With Ally

Scheana Shay is firing back at Billie Lee‘s claim of having propositioned her for a threesome.

On the latest episode of her podcast, the Vanderpump Rules star, 38, shot down the idea that she wanted to have a threesome with Billie, 39, while also sharing what she knows about the reason behind Rachel “Raquel” Leviss‘ split from James Kennedy, 32, and weighing in on Teddi Mellencamp‘s allegations regarding James and Ally Lewber‘s post-MTV Awards fight.

“Billie saying that I approached her for a threesome is inaccurate. I did have a conversation with her at Gay Pride season six, and I had made a comment about my then-boyfriend saying that if I ever had a threesome with him, he would like to have one with me and Billie,” Scheana explained on the February 16 episode of Scheananigans. “And I made that comment to her like, ‘Oh, just so you know, my boyfriend thinks you’re hot and said he wanted to have a threesome.’”

According to Scheana, who was dating actor Robert Parks-Valletta during season six, she and Billie laughed off the idea at the time.

“[Billie] was like, ‘We’re friends. That’s weird.’ I’m like ‘Oh no, no, no, no. I’m not down,’” Scheana revealed. “I think she maybe took that conversation as that’s how I was approaching her to have one, but no. My then-boyfriend was interested in one, but her and I were not, so I just wanna clear that up to anyone who was wondering.”

Moving on to the reason for Raquel, 29, and James’ split, which Raquel recently said would ruin James’ life, Scheana claimed Raquel repeatedly denied that any physical abuse had occurred.

“I actually had asked Raquel point blank about this multiple times because, as we’ve all seen on Vanderpump Rules, when James used to drink, he did have a lot of rage and anger and verbally wasn’t always the nicest. So I knew about the verbal abuse, obviously, that was also captured on the show, that’s no secret. But I was like, ‘Has it ever gone further?’ And she swore to me multiple times, ‘Never, never, never,’” Scheana confirmed.

Although Scheana said she knows why Raquel and James split, she won’t be sharing it on her podcast.

“[Raquel] confided in me about something that happened right before they broke up, but that is not my story to tell,” Scheana shared. “I can only imagine with her having a podcast now, she’s gonna eventually share that story, but that is not my story to tell here.”

As for James and Ally’s fight after the MTV Awards, Scheana said she believes Ally, who recently insisted James did not get physical with her after Teddi, 42, alluded to the idea on her Two Ts in a Pod podcast.

“I think it can be true that Ally wasn’t the victim of physical violence, but it can also be true that Teddi and [Tamra Judge] witnessed that old rage crazy behavior from James that didn’t sit well with them,” Scheana suspected. “Maybe the way he lunged [to] grab her phone or something they thought was a little too aggressive or whatever they said happened, but I genuinely think that if someone had been in physical danger and if they witnessed something that bad, I would hope that authorities or someone would’ve been alerted, not just like, let’s get out of the car and then go to a party at TomTom.”

Vanderpump Rules season 11 airs Tuesdays at 8/7c on Bravo.